In Stanford Law Review, Prof. Victor Reconceptualizes Compulsory Copyright Licenses | Faculty Spotlight | Albany Law School
  • About
    • Overview
    • ABA Required Disclosures
    • Administration
    • Board of Trustees
    • Campus Policies and Notices
    • Employment
    • Events
    • Fact Sheet
    • General Directory
    • History
    • News
    • Our Affiliation with UAlbany
    • President and Dean Ouellette
    • Staff Directory
    • Strategic Plan
  • Admissions
    • Overview
    • J.D. Admissions
    • Graduate Admissions
    • Special Programs
    • Accepted Students
    • Check Application Status
    • Connect with Admissions
    • Make A Deposit
    • Financial Aid
    • Office of Admissions
  • Academics
    • Overview
    • Courses
    • Areas of Study
    • JD Program
    • Graduate Programs
    • Special Programs
    • Pathways Program
    • Experiential Learning
    • Learning Outcomes
    • Registrar
    • Academic Resources
    • Academic Partnerships
  • Careers
    • Overview
    • Students
    • Employers
    • Alumni
    • Connect to AlbanyLaw Link
    • Employment Outcomes
    • Where Our Graduates Work
    • Career and Professional Development Center
    • Contact the Career and Professional Development Center
    • Women's Leadership Initiative
  • Student Life
    • Overview
    • Campus Resources
    • Commencement
    • Diversity & Inclusion
    • Health and Wellness
    • Living and Learning in Albany
    • Student Organizations
    • Student Spotlight
    • Veteran Services
  • Centers
    • Overview
    • The Justice Center
    • Government Law Center
    • Center for Excellence in Law Teaching
    • Cybersecurity and Privacy Law Center
    • Center for Judicial Process
    • Institute for Financial Market Regulation
    • Center for Continuing Legal Education
  • Faculty
    • Overview
    • Faculty Directory
    • Faculty Achievements
    • Faculty Scholarship and Research
    • Faculty Spotlight
    • Endowed and Distinguished Professorships
  • Alumni & Giving
    • Overview
    • Upcoming Events
    • Giving
    • Search Directories
    • Regional Alumni Network
    • National Alumni Association
    • Reunion
    • Class Notes
    • Volunteer and Mentor
    • Shared Interest Groups
    • Kate Stoneman
    • Institutional Advancement Team
Turn on more accessible mode
Turn off more accessible mode

COVID-19: Community Updates and Resources

Albany Law School

Calendar
|
Portal
|
Contact Us
|
gift box Giving
Calendar
Giving
Contact Us
Alba
ny
Law School
Back
Sign In
This area will be filled in by content you create in your page layouts.
Skip Navigation LinksHome/Faculty/Faculty Spotlight/In Stanford Law Review, Prof. Victor Reconceptualizes Compulsory Copyright Licenses

In Stanford Law Review, Prof. Victor Reconceptualizes Compulsory Copyright Licenses

John Caher | 10/5/2020 |
View Archives »
Facebook | Twitter | Email
ContentImg01_250w
MainContent

Jacob VictorA fascination with intellectual property in law school, coupled with a clerkship for a federal judge who authored a seminal article on the fair use standard, led Jacob Victor on a professional journey that brought him to Albany in the middle of an international pandemic.

Professor Victor joined the Albany Law School faculty in July to teach intellectual property and property law, develop a program for students interested in innovation and technology-focused careers, and serve as faculty advisor to the Innovation Intensive apprenticeship clinic.

“IP is fascinating because it's an area that's constantly in flux as new technologies, court cases, and legislation change the law, as well as require us to reassess how best to realize the policy goals at the heart of the IP system,” Victor said.

Victor clerked for Judge Pierre Leval, now a senior judge of the Second Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals, who wrote an article for the Harvard Law Review in 1990 on fair use. Victor considers it “one of the most important pieces of legal scholarship ever written.”

“It's rare to see an article directly influence the Supreme Court, but that's exactly what happened in Campbell v. Acuff Rose, in which the Court adopted Judge Leval's conception of fair use,” he said.

Victor is making his own contribution to IP/copyright scholarship. His article, “Reconceptualizing Compulsory Copyright Licenses,” recently published in the Stanford Law Review, examines inherent tension between creator incentives and public access to cultural works.

Read on SSRN: Reconceptualizing Compulsory Copyright Licenses

Among other things, he contends that the Music Modernization Act (MMA) signed by President Trump may hurt consumers by changing the criteria used to set royalty rates for streaming services. Victor said the merits of compulsory licensing are largely being ignored in new legislation.

“Compulsory licensing has been, and should continue to be, one of the most important tools that copyright law uses to balance between the twin goals of providing financial incentives to creators and providing the public with access to cultural works,” he said.

Victor’s article traces the lengthy evolution of copyright law’s approach to compulsory licensing vis-à-vis the music industry, and chronicles the technological and cultural changes that the law has at times struggled to keep pace with, partially because music implicates two distinct copyright interests: the musical composition and the recorded version of the song.

“The result is a highly complex web of regulation that subjects different forms of dissemination, even forms of dissemination that seem nearly identical, to different forms of licensing—either compulsory or free market licensing,” Victor writes.

Compulsory licensing dates to the 1909 Copyright Act, which aimed to regulate the conversion of sheet music into mechanically playable forms such as player piano rolls and the phonograph. It allowed anyone to license musical works, for a government-set rate, without the express permission of the owner.

Victor defends compulsory licensing because it enables distributors such as Pandora to make music accessible without engaging in endless negotiations with myriad copyright owners. He argues that the Copyright Act’s compulsory licensing schemes are motivated by an impulse similar to fair use and explained brilliantly by his former mentor, Judge Leval: ensuring public access to creative works without undermining the incentive to create.

“Judge Leval's theory of fair use strongly influences my scholarship,” Victor said. “In particular, his emphasis on reorienting the doctrine to more closely reflect the policy goals at the heart of the copyright system has inspired a lot of my research into how other areas of the copyright system, such as compulsory licensing, can better reflect those goals.”

Although IP law is generally federal, Victor said there are state law considerations as well.

“Most of the well-known areas of IP—copyright, trademark, patent—are federal,” Victor acknowledges. “But state government still plays an important role in other areas, such as trade secret law and the right of publicity. New York State has been working on right of publicity reform for the last few years and I think that will be a live issue for a while.” 

Victor’s scholarship has been published in the Yale Law Journal and the Cornell International Law Journal, and in addition to the Stanford article he has a forthcoming piece on “Utility-Expanding Fair Use” in the Minnesota Law Review.

“I hope my scholarship encourages courts, legislators and academics to view compulsory licensing as a tool that’s still relevant to creating good copyright policy, as well as lead to more thoughtful changes to  current law,” said Victor, who previously taught at New York University School of Law and litigated copyright, trademark and trade secret cases as an associate at Kirkland & Ellis.

ContentImg02_250w
MainContent02
ContentImg03_250w
MainContent03
ContentImg04_250w
MainContent04

  • Faculty
    • Faculty Directory
    • Faculty Achievements
      • Faculty In The News
      • Faculty Presentations
      • Faculty Publications
      • Faculty Recognition
    • Faculty Scholarship and Research
      • Faculty Blogs
      • Faculty Books
      • Faculty on SSRN
      • Gathii Faculty Workshops
    • Faculty Spotlight
    • Endowed and Distinguished Professorships
This area will be filled in by content you create in your page layouts.
This area will be filled in by content you create in your page layouts.
This area will be filled in by content you create in your page layouts.

Albany Law School Building Logo

Albany Law School

Better Opportunities. Bigger Impact.
80 New Scotland Avenue
Albany, NY 12208-3494
PHONE: 518-445-2311
  • Consumer Information (ABA Required Disclosures)
  • Events
  • Employment
  • News
  • Fact Sheet
  • Law Library
  • Faculty Directory
  • General Directory
  • Staff Directory
© Albany Law School | Site Map | Campus Policies | Privacy Policy | Contact Us